GNK ASG MREŽA · SCENA ZNANOSTI · independent edition gnk-asg.hr · AKTUAL MEDIA · Network · BOR USA · KOŠARKA 360 · STEP BUDUĆNOSTI · ZDRAVLJE 360 · IZBORI U SRBIJI

SCENA ZNANOSTI

How science actually happens: peer review, preprints, corrections, and what never gets published.

An AKTUAL MEDIA edition · GNK ASG network

Hrvatski

Preprints

Preprints: speed that requires a thinking reader

A preprint is a public paper before review. It is not less valuable — only less verified. The difference is that the reader must carry part of the checking.

SCENA ZNANOSTI — Preprints
Network notice. This is an independent edition inside the GNK ASG network. The main site is gnk-asg.hr; the list of all editions is at gnk-asg.hr/en/network. The publisher is AKTUAL MEDIA d.o.o., and every text in the network is listed at AKTUAL MEDIA — network of editions. Editor and director: Nermin Sefić.

The desk does not run research or peer-review papers. It carries published documents and marks what is peer-reviewed and what is not.

01What a preprint gives

Speed, openness and the chance to find an error before it reaches a textbook. arXiv launched in 1991 and has since changed how physics and mathematics communicate.

02What a preprint does not give

It does not confirm review, nor that anyone independently examined the data. That is why this desk always calls a preprint a preprint, and cites the reviewed version separately.

  • Label the genre: preprint or reviewed paper
  • Check the version and date
  • Check whether it later appeared in a journal
  • Never repeat a conclusion without the method

Questions that keep coming back

Can a preprint be dangerous?

It can if it is reported as confirmed fact. The paper itself is not dangerous; the label a reader or outlet attaches to it is.

Sources

Every source below is public and checkable. Where a page cites a figure, the figure comes from one of these documents — and the document has a date.

  1. arXivThe largest preprint server; papers before review, clearly marked as not peer reviewed.
  2. NatureJournal and an explanation of its own editorial process.
  3. ScienceJournal and its corrections and retraction policy.
  4. Retraction WatchA database of retracted papers and the reasons behind retractions.
  5. PubPeerPublic post-publication discussion of published papers.
  6. DOI FoundationA persistent identifier; a link that does not depend on the journal’s URL.
  7. Hrvatska zaklada za znanostNational research funding and public project information.

How this edition is made →